|
|
||||||||
ORIGINAL RESEARCH |
From the Division of Maternal Fetal Medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Ohio State University College of Medicine, Columbus, Ohio.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods: We reviewed 156 anti-Kell-positive pregnancies seen from 1959 to 1995, which were managed with serial maternal titers, amniotic fluid
OD450 determination, and funipuncture. Data on maternal titers, paternal phenotypes, invasive fetal testing and therapies, and neonatal outcomes were collected and analyzed to determine whether severely affected pregnancies were identified in time for successful fetal and neonatal therapy.
Results: Twenty-one fetuses were affected, eight with severe disease, and two fetuses in this group died. All of the severely affected fetuses were associated with maternal serum titers of at least 1:32. A critical titer of 1:32 was found to be 100% sensitive for identifying the affected pregnancies. The affected group had significantly higher amniotic fluid
OD450 values over the range of gestational ages than did the unaffected group (P < .001). The upper Liley curve was a specific discriminator for the diagnosis of affected fetuses, and the lower curve was specific for the diagnosis of unaffected or mild cases.
Conclusion: Fetal anemia due to anti-Kell isoimmunization might be due in part to erythropoietic suppression, but it is still largely a hemolytic process. The methods based on a hemolytic process, including use of a critical maternal serum titer of 1:32, serial amniotic fluid analyses when the titer was exceeded, and liberal use of funipuncture, were successful in identifying severely affected fetuses.
Widespread use of antiRh-D immunoglobulin (Ig) in pregnant women who are D-antigen negative has led to an increasing proportion of isoimmunization due to atypical, nonRh-D antibodies. Pregnancies complicated by isoimmunization due to atypical antibodies are generally managed in the same way as those with anti-D isoimmunization, which is largely a hemolytic process.13 Isoimmunization to the Kell antigen is a common cause of fetal and neonatal anemia due to one of these atypical antibodies.1
The Kell protein is a 93-kd transmembrane metallopeptidase important in the processing and metabolism of peptide hormones, and is believed to play a role in erythrocyte growth and differentiation.4,5 The antigenic nature of this protein can induce a pronounced isoimmune response in antigen-negative women exposed to Kell antigen-positive red blood cells (RBCs) through donor blood transfusions or transplacental passage of fetal RBCs during pregnancy. It has been proposed that the mechanism of fetal and neonatal anti-Kell isoimmune anemia is not solely hemolysis, as is the case with Rh disease, and that erythroid suppression is also important.6,7 The use of maternal history, critical serum titers, and spectrophotometric determination of amniotic fluid (AF) bilirubin in the monitoring of fetal anemia is predicated on a maternal alloimmune process that destroys fetal erythrocytes. Because this methodology relies on markers of maternal immune system activity and fetal hemolysis, it may not be adequate for pregnancies complicated by anti-Kell isoimmunization with possible hyporegenerative rather than hemolytic anemia.
We analyzed retrospectively the 37-year experience at the Ohio State University in the management of pregnancies complicated by anti-Kell isoimmunization. During this period, the management protocol developed for antiRh-D isoimmunization was used for anti-Kell, and we assessed its efficacy.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Data included maternal demographics and pregnancy history, paternal antigen testing, maternal indirect antiglobulin tests, results of optical density at 450 nm (
OD450), fetal hematocrit, fetal total bilirubin, and percentages of nucleated fetal RBCs. Neonatal data included gestational age at delivery, birth weight, delivery hematocrit and total bilirubin, cord indirect antiglobulin test results and Kell antigen status, neonatal morbidity, and necessary treatment(s). To avoid potential confounding effects, we analyzed only data obtained before the initiation of therapy. Initial maternal titer and paternal antigen data were available for all pregnancies. Complete maternal and neonatal data were available for all patients who had invasive procedures (ie, amniocentesis, funipuncture, and transfusion). When patients had more than one anti-Kell isoimmunized pregnancy, only the initial pregnancy was included in the analyses. Patients with incomplete data were excluded.
Maternal titers were measured every 46 weeks when paternal antigen testing was Kell positive or unknown. Standard tube techniques for the indirect Coombs test, as endorsed by the American Association of Blood Banks,8 were used to determine antibody titers. Amniocentesis for spectrophotometric determination of AF bilirubin pigment was done when there was a history of an affected infant or when maternal antibody titers were greater than 1:16. The results were plotted on a modified version of the Liley graph that used the original zones defined by Liley9,10 but that also included lower gestational ages down to 20 weeks. The portion from 20 to 28 weeks was developed in the 1960s for the management of Rh disease and was validated with data obtained from patients at the Ohio State University (
OShaughnessy, Amniotic fluid spectrophotometry is useful after 20 weeks gestation in the care of pregnancies complicated by red blood cell isoimmunization [abstract]. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1991;164:256). Since 1986, funipuncture has been done when the change in
OD450 was in the upper half of Liley zone II or in Liley zone III and the gestational age was remote from term.
Analyses of fetal blood included hemoglobin levels, total and direct bilirubin, and percentage of nucleated RBCs. For this analysis, we categorized the affected fetuses by the degree of neonatal anemia using thresholds similar to those defined by Liley: mild (neonatal hemoglobin at least 11 g/dL) or severe (neonatal hemoglobin 10.9 g/dL or less).9,10 Anemia was also defined as severe when hydrops fetalis was present or when fetal or neonatal blood transfusion was required. Delivery or fetal transfusion was done when severe fetal anemia (hemoglobin less than 10 g/dL) or hydrops fetalis was present. Umbilical cord blood specimens collected at delivery were tested for bound anti-Kell Ig by direct Coombs testing and for erythrocyte Kell antigen status.
Statistical and data analyses were done with JMP Statistical Discovery Software (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC) and Microsoft Excel (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA). Alpha of .05 was considered significant. The Levene test was applied on continuous variables to test for equal variances. When variances were equal, Student t-test was used; otherwise Welch analysis of variance was performed.11 Fisher exact test was used for comparisons involving two groups of nominal or ordinal variables. Analysis of variance for repeated measures was used to compare the mean responses of groups when there were multiple observations of a continuous variable over time.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Paternal serum testing for RBC Kell typing was done when paternity was certain. Paternal antigen status was considered unknown when paternity was not certain. Of the 103 paternal serum samples analyzed for Kell antigen, 34 (33%) were Kell positive. The 53 pregnancies with unknown paternal antigen status were considered at risk, for a total of 87 at-risk pregnancies in 75 women. Forty-seven women (63%) at risk had a history of a blood transfusion, 12 (16%) had a known negative history of receiving blood products, and 16 (21%) did not have documentation or could not recall.
One at-risk pregnancy that ended in fetal death (described later) was not included in the following analyses because of incomplete data. Twenty-one infants (24%), born to 20 at-risk women, were affected. Three of 52 pregnancies (5.8%) with unknown paternal Kell antigen status were affected, and 18 of 34 paternal Kell antigenpositive pregnancies (53%) were affected. No affected infants resulted from pregnancies with a negative paternal antigen status. Twenty infants from the at-risk pregnancies had umbilical cord blood that was Kell antigen positive. Eighteen umbilical cord blood specimens collected at delivery had positive direct antiglobulin tests. Two infants with severe anemia had negative cord blood direct antiglobulin tests at delivery, but both had received fetal transfusions, and one previously had a positive direct antiglobulin test from a funipuncture specimen. The other received two intraperitoneal transfusions in 1982, before the use of funipuncture at our institution, and fetal blood was not available for direct Coombs analysis in this case. Umbilical cord blood was not collected from one pregnancy that ended in fetal death at 25 weeks gestation because of severe hydrops fetalis. This pregnancy was believed to be affected based on the clinical presentation of an elevated maternal serum anti-Kell titer of 1:32 and AF
OD450 in Liley zone II.
Eight infants (9.3%) among the at-risk pregnancies were severely affected. Table 1
presents the maternal data and neonatal outcomes of the eight severely affected infants. Two cases (2.3%) ended in fetal death, and among three cases (3.5%) of hydrops fetalis, one fetus died. In this case, from 1979 (Table 1
, no. 7), the woman first presented for prenatal care at 25 weeks gestation, and an anti-Kell titer of 1:32 was found on her serum screen. Amniocentesis and ultrasound were performed 2 days later and revealed hydrops fetalis; the fetus died on the same day. The second fetal death occurred after a transfusion and was procedure related. A third fetal death occurred in a woman with anti-Kell isoimmunization (titer 1:1024) at 39 weeks gestation. This death occurred in 1966 and we were unable to confirm the clinical circumstances, so we did not include this pregnancy in our analyses. The neonate of subject no. 8 was delivered at 36 weeks and had umbilical cord hemoglobin of 11.0 g/dL at delivery, but the neonates hemoglobin fell to 8.8 g/dL on the first day of life and a simple transfusion was given.
|
Table 2
presents maternal and neonatal data from the 13 infants with mild anti-Kell isoimmunization. Five of the mildly affected fetuses had at least one funipuncture (range one to seven) for fetal blood analysis but did not require fetal therapy. One neonate required one simple transfusion on the fourth day of life, but the direct antiglobulin test on umbilical cord blood was positive for multiple maternal antibodies in addition to anti-Kell, and the anemia could not be considered solely due to anti-Kell. The mildly affected group included one nullipara, eight parous women with negative histories of affected infants, two women who might have had previous affected infants, and one woman with a confirmed affected infant in the past. The first two women had a history of two infants with hyperbilirubinemia requiring phototherapy and one infant with a history of "anemia," respectively. These previous pregnancies were cared for at another facility and their data were not included in this analysis. The third woman previously had a mildly affected fetus (Table 2
). In the second affected pregnancy, she had a funipuncture at 25 weeks gestation that did not demonstrate marked fetal anemia, and she was followed with serial amniocenteses that remained in the lower half of Liley zone II.
|
Amniocentesis for
OD450 was done in 36 women in their initial isoimmunized pregnancies. Twelve had affected pregnancies and 24 had pregnancies resulting in Kell-negative neonates. Sixty-four amniocenteses were done in the affected group and 46 in the unaffected group. The mean gestational age at amniocentesis was significantly less in the affected group than in the unaffected group (26.0 ± 4.5 weeks versus 29.9 ± 4.2 weeks; P < .001). To consider the effect of gestational age on
OD450, we stratified the data by gestational age at amniocentesis into three groups: less than 25 weeks, 2532 weeks, and greater than 32 weeks. The gestational age groupings were chosen because the clinical significance of an affected pregnancy is substantially different for each of these ranges of gestational age. Analysis of variance with repeated measures was performed on the stratified data of log10 of the
OD450 values to ascertain the difference between the affected and unaffected groups, taking into account the repeated measures and the fact that
OD450 varied over gestational age (R2 = 0.92). The affected group had significantly higher
OD450 values than the unaffected group over the range of gestational ages (P < .001). The gestational age effect was also significant (P < .001).
Figure 1
contains the AF data obtained prior to the initiation of therapy with the affected group separated into severe and mild cases. The severely affected pregnancies are identified by numbers that correspond to the patient numbers in Table 1
. Serial measurements for the severely affected pregnancies are connected with solid lines. Figure 1
also shows the modified Liley curves used at the Ohio State University for the management of Rh disease. Although the
OD450 is an indirect measure of fetal anemia, the upper Liley curve proved to be a specific discriminator for diagnosing affected fetuses, and the lower curve was a specific discriminator for diagnosing unaffected or mild cases.
|
Neonatal umbilical cord blood specimens were collected at delivery in 18 affected and 24 unaffected pregnancies. The mean gestational age at delivery did not differ between the groups: 37.4 ± 2.9 weeks for the affected group (n = 18) versus 36.0 ± 3.2 weeks in the unaffected group (n = 24) (P = .16). The mean neonatal hemoglobin level was significantly lower in the affected group: 13.6 ± 2.6 g/dL (n = 18) versus 15.9 ± 2.6 g/dL in the unaffected group (n = 24) (P = .007). The total bilirubin levels did not differ significantly between the groups: 3.1 ± 1.4 mg/dL (n = 15) versus 3.2 ± 1.7 mg/dL (n = 15), respectively (P = .8).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the 1980s, it was recognized that Kell-isoimmunized pregnancies did not always evolve in the same manner as those sensitized with antiRh-D.13,19 Several other investigators reported large series (more than 100 pregnancies) of anti-Kell isoimmunization, and all but one study found that severely affected pregnancies had maternal titers of at least 1:32.1518 Bowman et al18 reported 31 pregnancies affected with Kell isoimmunization. Seventeen pregnancies were severely affected, and all but one had maternal serum titers of 1:32 or greater. In the single exception, the woman presented with a grossly hydropic fetus at 23 weeks gestation, had a titer of 1:8, and had no history of an affected infant.18 In our series, none of the severely affected pregnancies had a titer less than 1:32, which we found to be a sensitive discriminator for pregnancies that required amniocentesis.
The reliability of
OD450 values in Kell isoimmunization has been questioned because of reports of more serious fetal anemia presenting at lower values.16,19 Figure 1
depicts the trend of higher
OD450 values for affected fetuses, which is consistent with a hemolytic process. Caine and Mueller-Heubach16 and Bowman et al18 found AF analysis to be reliable in most instances, but both groups had difficulty diagnosing the affected pregnancies when serial values of
OD450 dropped from Liley zone II into zone I, particularly at gestational ages over 32 weeks. In our series,
OD450 was specific but not sensitive in distinguishing affected from unaffected fetuses. The values that fell in the middle zone (zone II) were not easily categorized, and those pregnancies required careful further analysis with serial amniocenteses and often funipuncture. In some affected pregnancies,
OD450 values dropped into a lower zone when serial values were collected, but no severely affected fetuses fell into and stayed within zone I. In unaffected pregnancies, serial
OD450 values decreased as gestational age increased. Funipuncture for fetal hemoglobin is recommended when the rate of decline of serial
OD450 measurements decreases or reaches a plateau. Caution should be exercised when using
OD450 values, especially when they fall in the middle zone. The limitations of AF analysis as an indirect indicator of fetal anemia should be recognized.
Our data from the funipuncture and umbilical cord specimens showed significantly lower hemoglobin levels in the affected fetuses and neonates. Total bilirubin levels did not differ significantly between affected and unaffected fetuses and neonates. The percentage of fetal nucleated RBCs also did not differ between the groups. These findings are consistent with a hyporegenerative pathophysiology. Vaughan et al6 and Weiner and Widness7 reported decreased laboratory indices (fetal reticulocytes, bilirubin, and nucleated RBCs) of fetal erythropoiesis and hemolysis in pregnancies complicated by Kell isoimmunization, and Vaughan et al5 recently demonstrated, in vitro, a dose-dependent suppression of hematopoietic progenitor cells by serum from women with circulating anti-Kell antibodies. Our experience suggests that although fetal anemia due to anti-Kell might be due in part to suppression of fetal erythropoiesis, the elevated
OD450 levels in the affected pregnancies indicate that the mechanism of anemia is also a hemolytic process.
Our management approach to pregnancies complicated by Rh isoimmunization has proved successful in managing more than 150 pregnancies with anti-Kell isoimmunization at the Ohio State University since 1959. Using our investigation guidelines, we did not have a single undiagnosed, severely affected fetus. There was one fetal death directly attributable to isoimmunization; however, the woman presented late for prenatal care with a hydropic fetus. This case (Table 1
, no. 7) underscores the importance of early prenatal care in the diagnosis and management of isoimmunization. In addition, the fetus might have survived with modern sonography and fetal therapy. Maternal antibody titers with a threshold for amniocentesis of greater than 1:16 and
OD450 determinations are important in deciding which pregnancies need additional investigations such as fetal blood sampling. Fetal Kell antigen typing from amniocytes should decrease the number of blood samplings done on antigen-negative fetuses.20,21 A high index of suspicion should be maintained because the evaluations are not uniformly consistent with a purely hemolytic process. It is possible that erythroid suppression can mask the traditional indirect characteristics of fetal anemia. Bowman et al18 suggested adopting a lower critical titer of 1:8 for anti-Kell isoimmunization. A lower threshold might increase sensitivity, but our data do not support this because all of our severely affected pregnancies had titers of at least 1:32.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Support for statistical analysis was provided by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) General Clinical Research Center at the Ohio State University (grant no. NIH-M01-RR-00034).
Received June 25, 1998. Received in revised form September 29, 1998. Accepted October 22, 1998.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2. Jackson M, Branch DW. Isoimmunization in pregnancy. In: Gabbe SG, Niebyl JR, Simpson JL, eds. Obstetrics: Normal and problem pregnancies. 3rd ed. New York: Churchill Livingstone, 1996:899932.
3. Weinstein L. Irregular antibodies causing hemolytic disease of the newborn: A continuing problem. Clin Obstet Gynecol 1982;25:32132.[Medline]
4. Turner AJ, Tanzawa K. Mammalian membrane metallopeptidases: NEP, ECE, KELL, and PEX. FASEB J 1997;11:35564.[Abstract]
5. Vaughan JI, Manning M, Warwick RM, Letsky EA, Murray NA, Roberts IAG. Inhibition of erythroid progenitor cells by anti-Kell antibodies in fetal alloimmune anemia. N Engl J Med 1998;338: 798803.
6. Vaughan JI, Warwick R, Letsky E, Nicolini U, Rodeck CH, Fisk NM. Erythropoietic suppression in fetal anemia because of Kell alloimmunization. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1994;171:24752.[Medline]
7. Weiner CP, Widness JA. Decreased fetal erythropoiesis and hemolysis in Kell hemolytic anemia. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1996;174:54751.[Medline]
8. American Association of Blood Banks. Technical manual of the American Association of Blood Banks. 9th ed. Arlington, Virginia: American Association of Blood Banks, 1985.
9. Liley AW. Liquor amnii analysis in the management of the pregnancy complicated by rhesus sensitization. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1961;82:135970.[Medline]
10. Liley AW. Assessment of hemolytic disease from amniotic fluid. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1963;86:48594.[Medline]
11. Sall J, Lehman A. JMP start statistics: A guide to statistics and data analysis using JMP and JMP IN software. 1st ed. Belmont, California: Duxbury Press, 1996:11547.
12. Frigoletto FD, Davies IJ. Erythroblastosis fetalis with hydrops resulting from anti-Kell isoimmune disease. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1977;127:887.[Medline]
13. Barss VA, Benacerraf BR, Greene MF, Phillippe M, Frigoletto FD. Sonographic detection of fetal hydrops. A report of two cases. J Reprod Med 1985;30:8934.[Medline]
14. Marsh WL, Redman CM. The Kell blood group system: A review. Transfusion 1990;30:15867.[Medline]
15. Wenk RE, Goldstein P, Felix JK. Kell alloimmunization, hemolytic disease of the newborn, and perinatal management. Obstet Gynecol 1985;66:4736.
16. Caine ME, Mueller-Heubach E. Kell sensitization in pregnancy. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1986;154:8590.[Medline]
17. Leggat HM, Gibson JM, Barron SL, Reid MM. Anti-Kell in pregnancy. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1991;98:1625.[Medline]
18. Bowman JM, Pollock JM, Manning FA, Harman CR, Menticoglou S. Maternal Kell blood group alloimmunization. Obstet Gynecol 1992;79:23944.
19. Berkowitz RL, Beyth Y, Sadovsky E. Death in utero due to Kell sensitization without excessive elevation of the delta OD40 value in amniotic fluid. Obstet Gynecol 1982;60:7469.
20. Lee S, Bennet PR, Overton T, Warwick R, Wu X, Redman C. Prenatal diagnosis of Kell blood group genotypes: KEL1 and KEL2. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1996;175:4559.[Medline]
21. Spence WC, Maddalena A, Demers DB, Bick DP. Prenatal determination of genotypes Kell and Cellano in at-risk pregnancies. J Reprod Med 1997;42:3537.[Medline]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |